Published Oct. 09, 2024

As New Brunswick heads into its provincial election, a major legal battle over Aboriginal title looms. The Wolastoqey Nation’s lawsuit, which challenges provincial and federal governments along with private landowners, including timber companies, could reshape over half of New Brunswick’s territory. The case, involving six Indigenous communities and over 400,000 non-Indigenous residents, is currently before Justice Kathryn Gregory, with key decisions expected by December.

Political leaders are divided on how to proceed. Progressive Conservative Leader Blaine Higgs insists on continuing litigation, citing concerns over private property rights. In contrast, Liberal Leader Susan Holt and Green Party Leader David Coon advocate for halting the lawsuit to allow for negotiations with Indigenous leaders. Holt believes negotiations could resolve the issue without further costly legal battles, while Coon points to successful models in British Columbia.

The dispute centers on the recognition of Aboriginal title to land traditionally occupied by the Wolastoqey Nation. While the government maintains that private land rights are incompatible with such claims, Indigenous leaders argue they have long sought meaningful negotiations. Chief Patricia Bernard of the Wolastoqey Nation criticizes the government’s refusal to engage seriously in talks, while other First Nations leaders express a willingness to negotiate if the government demonstrates good faith. The outcome of this case could have far-reaching implications for land use, economic development, and Indigenous relations in the province.

To read the full article, click here.